Shell shock thesis

Show full item record Abstract Historians have identified shell-shock, a contemporary umbrella term for the range of nervous and mental afflictions suffered by soldiers in the First World War, as a key episode in the transition to modern psychological approaches to mental disorder in Britain. This thesis argues that wartime theories of shell-shock display considerable continuity with central tenets of pre-war psychological medicine. An approach to the history of shell-shock which emphasises continuity opens new perspectives on the significance of the episode for British psychiatry and society in the early twentieth century.

Shell shock thesis

Millions of soldiers died in the trenches.

Shell shock thesis

Others suffered from severe psychologically traumas. The majority of the soldiers, who suffered from psychologically traumas, were never able to return to the battle field. Experts were desperate to find a cure, but the regeneration hospitals remained unsuccessful during the war.

Many of the soldiers, who suffered from shell shock, were haunted by the cruel memories for a lifetime. The author of the text is Professor Joana Bourke. The intended audience is perhaps those, who are generally interested in history and also those, whose specific focus is World War One.

The medium, in which the text occurs, is an online website founded by BBC. The general purpose of the text is to enlighten and expository the reader.

As the headliner emphasises the article is about shell shock during World War One. The article focus on the mental traumas, which many soldier experienced during World War. The article deals with medical symptoms, how to define trauma and furthermore how the traumas may be cured.

The argumentation plays a minor role in the article. As mentioned before the articles intention is neither to persuade nor propagandize. The article is a historically exposition. The author makes a statement, that the psychological traumas played a major role during World War One.

The statement is not presented as openly and directly as if it was a clear argument. Furthermore it is difficult to define trauma and find a solution to the suffering. Millions of British and German, both soldiers and officers, suffered from shell shock and a possible cure was unrealistic.

Generally the language is really objective. Very few adjectives are used in the article, which makes it hard to determine, what the arguments are and how they are presented.

Overall the language is rather easy to understand. Even though the main part of the article is rather easy to understand the quotes from World War One, which she emphasises a lot in the article, are difficult to understand, because the way of writing has changed over the decades and is therefore different to ours.

I really enjoyed reading the article. It gives a huge amount of information and insight knowledge concerning the war. She emphasises personal experiences and quotes from World War One, which makes it easier to relate to.

The article is very well-written, because it varies between short and long sentences, which gives the article variation and dynamic. I think that the article gives a realistic and objective description of World War One. The aim of the article is neither to persuade nor propagandize and therefore I believe it a reliable source if you want to seek information about Shell Shock during World War One.

A few things I would like to point out in the article are the conflict defining when a soldier was ready to return to the battlefield after regeneration at the hospital. The conflict between the soldiers, who wanted to return to the battlefield and the doctors, who disagreed with them is not pointed out.

But perhaps it would make the article more subjective, which clearly is not the intention of the author. Bloody saliva Dribbles down his shapeless jacket. I saw him stab And stab again A well-killed Boche.

Shell-shock in First World War Britain: an intellectual and medical history, cc

The poem describes the horrible scenarios of the trenches, which made tons of soldiers physically marked for the rest of their lives. By emphasizing the war poem it becomes easier to relate to the cruel experiences the soldiers experienced during World War One.

He will be sent to a regeneration hospital, where the memories of the horrible war will haunt him forever. He will perhaps never return to the battlefield again. Overall the context of the article is very objective and very few adjectives are used.

The way the quotes from the war itself gives an insight knowledge, which can be used to establish a realistic image of that time. By quoting the author successfully emphasises personal experiences during World War One, which makes the article interesting to read.

The mix between the objective exposition and the subjective quotations from the individuals, who experienced World War One, makes the article historical reliable and gives insight knowledge as well.

Choose Type of service."Shell Shock During World War One" Essay. The Great War, later renamed World War One, was mainly a battle between the German and the English troops - "Shell Shock During World War One" Essay introduction.

Millions of soldiers died in the trenches. This thesis examines how Nick displays himself as predisposed to shell shock before going to World War I and the tension surrounding why a person becomes shell shocked.

Dissertation submitted to the University of Sheffield in partial The third and final part of the thesis is a critical appraisal of the shell concussion and shell shock which was considered to be psychological, not neurological in origin.

At this time analytical. Thesis Statement: Shell shock is an epidemic that affects men during wartime and the treatment of shell shock victims varies widely; ranging from the use of disciplinary approach or practices up to the use of technological advancements such as the electro-shock treatment.

Dissertation submitted to the University of Sheffield in partial The third and final part of the thesis is a critical appraisal of the shell concussion and shell shock which was considered to be psychological, not neurological in origin.

At this time analytical. To this extent, his research mounts only a limited challenge to conventional views of shell shock as a gendered diagnosis, and even confirms a .

Perspectives on ‘shell shock’ | World War I Centenary